The False Sister by Briar Ripley Page – Horror Book Review

The False Sister by Briar Ripley Page

A Horror Book Review by Carmilla Voiez

Brilliant, intelligent and heart-wrenching. This story delivers a punch in the gut to anyone who didn’t manage to live up to their parents’ expectations.

At the tender age of twelve, Jesse is torn from his home in the city and brought to a small town where it seems impossible for a young autistic boy to make new friends. But at least he still has his older sister, Crys, a moody and difficult daughter as far as their parents are concerned, but also a loving sister and fierce advocate for Jesse. Then one night she vanishes.

Jesse believes his sister is dead. Even when Crys returns home, she seems so different, so strange, that he’d sooner believe in pod-people than accept this teenager who calls herself Crystal is really his sister. His parents had seemed strangely unconcerned while Crys was missing, and now they welcome the imposter into their home without question, fawning over her new feminine appearance and good manners. Jesse despairs that he will never be able to get them to accept the truth.

I was hugely impressed by this novella. The twelve-year-old narrator’s voice was childlike but never childish. The sentences were mainly short with simple structures, and the words used felt as though they belonged in any intelligent young person’s vocabulary. That Page could maintain this style without the rhythm becoming repetitive, is a testament to their talent. 

Briar Riley Page does an amazing job of portraying the fluidity and uncertainty of many teenagers’ and tweens’ sense of identity while exploring the myriad of experiences and things that may or may not feel erotic depending on context. This treacherous ground is navigated in a way that feels appropriate for young adult readers as well as those whose adolescence is, thankfully, a distant nightmare. 

Jesse’s dreams and encounters with his neighbour display a growing awareness of his own burgeoning sexuality, but perhaps because of the gulf between him and his peers, he is able to probe and wrestle with these new discoveries free from outside interference. 

The False Sister is both an effective horror story and a Bildungsroman where the main character comes face to face with the unimaginable, learns to accept and appreciate the diversity of human experience, and realises that the adults who are supposed to protect them are more concerned about their status in the community and what their neighbours think.   

The False Sister by Briar Ripley Page

It’s 1994, and Jesse Greer’s troubled older sister, Crys, has run away from home. Shy, socially awkward Jesse assumes that she has returned to her old haunts in the big city – until he discovers Crys’ remains in the woods behind his family’s house. Traumatised, Jesse runs to his parents for help, only to find that Crys has returned home, alive.

The False Sister by Briar Ripley Page

The Heart and Soul of Horror Book Review Websites


  • Carmilla Voiez

    Carmilla Voiez is a British horror and fantasy writer living in Scotland. Her influences include Graham Masterton, Thomas Ligotti, and Clive Barker. She is pansexual and passionate about intersectional feminism and human rights. Carmilla has a First-Class Bachelor’s degree in Creative Writing and Linguistics. Her work includes stories in horror anthologies published by Crystal Lake Publishing, Clash Books and Mocha Memoirs; a co-authored Southern Gothic Horror novel; two self-published graphic novels, and the award-winning, dark fantasy/horror Starblood trilogy. Graham Masterton described the second book in her Starblood trilogy as a “compelling story in a hypnotic, distinctive voice that brings her eerie world vividly to life”. Carmilla is also a freelance editor and mentor who enjoys making language sing.

    View all posts