The eldest sister finally gets her turn, and the fated-mates chemistry more than earns it.
Hexy Beast | Avery Flynn | Berkley Romance | 8 September 2026 |
Effie Sherwood was meant to inherit the family power and instead watched it skip her for a younger sister, which is the wound this whole book is built on. Hexy Beast is the third Sherwood Witches novel from Avery Flynn, a spicy paranormal rom-com that throws an impulsive witch onto the back of a grumpy werewolf alpha’s motorcycle and lets the fated-mates mess sort itself out. It is funny, it is filthy, and it is the strongest thing Flynn has done in this world yet, one saggy middle stretch aside. Witch versus werewolf, enemies to lovers, forced proximity, the lot. If that is your poison, pour a large one.
Flynn writes desire without apology and banter without a safety net, and in Effie Sherwood she has built her most alive heroine yet. The middle wanders in the woods a beat too long, but this is the funniest, spiciest, most confident book in the series.
Hexy Beast by Avery Flynn: A Witch, a Werewolf and Spicy Rom-Com
The eldest child gets the blueprint and the disappointment both. First out of the gate, first to be measured, first to learn that the family has already decided who you are before you have worked it out for yourself. In the Sherwood house that blueprint went sideways, because the magic that should have crowned the firstborn skipped clean over Effie and settled on a younger sister instead. Which leaves Effie as the family’s designated live wire, the one nobody trusts near anything breakable, herself very much included.
That is the woman Flynn hands us, and she is the best thing on the page.
The setup is pure trope machinery, and Flynn knows it. Darius Aetos, alpha of a broke and cornered werewolf pack, tries to make off with a powerful Sherwood spellbook to sell to the Council. Effie, refusing to be the sister who stands by while the family gets robbed, launches herself onto his moving motorcycle to stop him.
She fails, gets carried off into pack territory as leverage, and then a meddling oracle of an aunt announces that the witch and the werewolf are fated mates. From there the two are bound so tightly they cannot physically pull apart, which is a neat and slightly cruel way of forcing a witch and a werewolf who loathe each other into the same small tent. Add a scheming second-in-command angling for Darius’s job, a Blue Moon gauntlet to survive, and a Council with its fingers in everything, and you have the shape of it.
What lifts this above the run of shifter romances is the voice. Effie narrates like a woman who has decided that if the universe is going to make her the punchline, she will at least write the joke herself. The comedy is loud, quick and unbothered, and Flynn leans into direct address and the odd wink to the reader, a device that will either delight you or grate depending on your tolerance for a heroine who occasionally talks to camera.
The book opens on Effie clocking the deeply inconvenient truth that she fancies the man who has just kidnapped her, and that gag, which I am paraphrasing rather than quoting, tells you the register immediately. Self-aware, a little rude, allergic to taking itself seriously. It sets the tone and, largely, the book keeps its promise.
Look closely at how that comedy actually works, because it is doing more than filling the silence. Effie’s narration runs in a breathless present tense, all asides and self-interruptions, and the jokes almost always land at her own expense. That is not a stylistic tic. It is characterisation smuggled in as comedy. A woman who has spent her whole life cast as the family embarrassment has learned to get the first laugh in before anyone else can, and Flynn lets that defensive reflex do the heavy lifting of telling us who Effie is without stopping to spell it out.
When the technique works, and it works often, the humour and the character become the same thing, each carrying the other. When it slips, and it does slip, the asides start performing for the reader rather than revealing the woman, and the fourth wall goes from a wink to a nudge to an elbow in the ribs. That line is thinner than Flynn always manages to walk.
The chemistry is the other engine. Darius is the grumpy to Effie’s chaos, an alpha so busy white-knuckling his own instincts that he mistakes control for leadership, and watching Effie prise his fingers off the wheel one at a time is the real pleasure here.
The banter lands. The spice, when it arrives around the two-fifths mark, is generous and frequent and does not fade to black, including a set piece at a waterfall that gives a few resident naiads an eyeful they did not sign up for. Flynn writes sex the way she writes everything else, with the handbrake off, and crucially she writes a heroine who wants what she wants and refuses to be ashamed of it. That refusal is not decoration. It is the whole point of Effie, and it is what makes the romance feel like it means something rather than just steaming up the windows.
There is a tonal risk that comes bundled with that energy, too. When Flynn’s comedy is on, it is very on, quick and daft and charming. When it misses, it tips into cheese, the joke reaching a beat past where it should have stopped, and a couple of the fourth-wall asides land with a clang rather than a wink. Your mileage will depend entirely on how much irreverence you like in your paranormal romance. I liked plenty. I could have done with slightly less winking and slightly more trusting the scene to be funny on its own.
A word on the audiobook, since a good chunk of this book’s early audience met it that way. The dual narration from Scott Rose and Kelli Tager pulls the two leads cleanly apart, giving Effie’s chaos and Darius’s growl their own room to breathe, and the banter in particular gains something from being performed rather than read off the page. If you are the sort of reader who finds heavy fourth-wall breaking easier to swallow in a voice than in print, the audio might be the version that wins you round. It is the same book either way. It simply hands you a different set of tools for enjoying it.
Set against Flynn’s own run, the trajectory is the story worth telling. Witcha Gonna Do?, the 2022 opener, introduced the Sherwood world and the non-magical sister Tilda with a lot of charm and a slightly unsteady hand on the worldbuilding. Head Witch in Charge sharpened things in 2025.
Hexy Beast is the one where the machine finally purrs, because the rules of this universe are established now, the stakes are laid in, and Flynn can spend her energy on character and heat instead of explaining how witchydom works. You can feel the confidence. A writer who has stopped worrying whether you will follow her and simply started showing off, which is exactly the moment a series like this should hit its stride.
On the shelf, it sits comfortably in the Berkley witchy-rom-com lane, the cosy-supernatural corner that Sangu Mandanna’s The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches helped popularise, though Flynn runs considerably hotter and considerably more chaotic than that comparison suggests. For the fated-mates, grumpy-alpha, unapologetically explicit shifter angle, Ali Hazelwood’s Bride is the nearer neighbour, while readers who came for the pun-forward witchy chaos will recognise the same gleeful register that runs through India Holton’s magical romps. Flynn is not reinventing the fated-mates trope so much as cheerfully weaponising it, and the book is honest about that. It wears every cliché on the outside of its jacket and dares you to have a problem with it. Mostly you will not.
Underneath the noise, the themes are sturdier than the packaging lets on. This is a book about the overlooked eldest finding out that being passed over is not the same as being worthless, about a pack learning that survival is a group project, and about desire treated as something to own rather than apologise for. Effie’s arc is really about a woman deciding she gets to define her own worth instead of accepting the family’s verdict, and Darius’s mirrors it, an alpha discovering that the strong move is to stop carrying everything alone. The self-acceptance message is not subtle. It does not need to be. It gives the froth a spine.
Hexy Beast is a witch on a stolen motorcycle with the wind in her hair and the pack politics she was never meant to survive.
Hexy Beast by Avery Flynn
An impulsive witch and a buttoned-up werewolf discover love is its own beast in this spicy rom-com from USA Today bestselling author Avery Flynn.
As the eldest daughter of the magical Sherwood family, I’m supposed to have everything together. Well, joke’s on them—I, Effie Sherwood, am chaos incarnate, and you’ll never be able to guess my next move.
Like jumping on the back of Darius Aetos’ motorcycle. Not only is Darius grumpy, gruff, and hot, he’s also the head of the Aetos werewolf pack.
My spur of the moment decision has quickly become a much bigger commitment, because a pack elder is convinced this hunk of a man (or wolf, depending on the hour) is my fated mate.
Even though I’m a witch and he’s a werewolf, we’re stuck together until we can find our way out of the tricky pack politics. But under the light of the blue moon, it’s almost starting to feel like Darius doesn’t want to stay away from me. And I’m not sure if it’s my magic going haywire or the starlit skies, but I can’t imagine leaving his arms either.
Ginger Nuts of Horror: The Heart and Soul of Horror Reviews
Looking to get your horror book or film in front of the genre’s most dedicated audience? Ginger Nuts of Horror is one of Europe’s largest independent horror review websites, with over 30 contributors publishing horror book reviews and horror movie reviews almost every single day.
We offer far more than reviews. Authors, filmmakers and publishers can promote their work through in-depth horror book reviews, horror film reviews, comic and video game coverage, news features, and our popular author and director interviews like Five Minutes With. Our guest feature series, The Horror of My Life, Childhood Fears, The ? That Made Me and more, let creators tell their story while promoting their latest release.
Every feature is built to sell your work. We include backlinks to your website or Amazon author page, a full synopsis, and a universal purchasing link that sends readers straight to their local store. Add a large, engaged social following and an 18-year archive of trusted horror coverage, and you have a platform genuinely built to grow your readership.
Whether you’re an established author, an indie filmmaker, or a debut voice in indie horror, there’s a way for us to help you reach more fans. Explore our horror book reviews and horror movie reviews, then get your horror book or film featured today.
